Welcome to Lugos NY Pizza
Nestled in Muskogee, OK, Lugos NY Pizza stands as a beacon for authentic New York-style pizza lovers. With a menu that boasts fresh ingredients and handcrafted dough—fermented for three days—the flavors come alive in every bite. Patrons rave about the crispy crust and generous portions, perfect for sharing or indulging solo. While there’s no dine-in option, the welcoming atmosphere and passionate owners make up for it. From classic Margherita to hearty Stromboli, every dish reflects a commitment to quality. For those seeking a hidden gem with a rich culinary story, Lugos NY Pizza is an essential stop for any food enthusiast.
-
520 E Okmulgee St, Muskogee, OK 74403, United States Hotline: +1 918-777-4090
Welcome to Lugos NY Pizza, where mouthwatering pizza meets the heart of Muskogee, Oklahoma. Nestled at 520 E Okmulgee St, this gem is not just a pizza place; it’s a culinary experience forged by passion and expertise. The founders, who've dedicated over 15 years to mastering the art of pizza making, have brought their New York roots to the heart of Oklahoma, and they're serving up some of the best slices you'll ever experience.
From the moment you step in, you'll feel the energetic vibe of the place. With no frills or fancy decor—just a couple of folding chairs and a counter where all the magic happens, Lugos focuses on what truly matters: great food. The enthusiasm of the staff is palpable, creating an inviting atmosphere where patrons instantly feel at home. Whether you’re talking to the friendly staff or watching them dance along to classic tunes, the positive energy elevates your dining experience.
Let’s talk pizza. Each pie at Lugos is crafted from scratch, with a commitment to quality that shines through in every bite. Customers rave about the crispy crust that strikes the perfect balance between thin and sturdy, allowing it to be both crispy and soft. The dough is meticulously fermented for three days, resulting in a unique flavor profile that sets it apart from ordinary pizzerias. Add to that the freshness of locally sourced ingredients—from the vibrant veggies to the sumptuous meats—and you’ve got a winning recipe that has patrons declaring this their new favorite spot.
Reviews tell a story. One customer delightfully noted that they devoured the entire pizza crust, a feat they usually wouldn’t consider. The flavors are balanced; the sauce is fresh and light, while the cheese is succulent and indulgent. A 20-inch cheese pizza or a flavorful 12-inch veggie pie are just a few of the options that have everyone coming back for more. The buffalo wings, too, have received high praises for their tantalizing taste, making it hard to resist adding them to your order.
While Lugos may operate as a pick-up-and-go establishment, the quality of their offerings is what keeps people coming back. From their delicious Stromboli to the savory calzones, each dish is prepared with the same meticulous attention to detail. Customers have even remarked that one Stromboli can provide multiple meals, showcasing Lugos's dedication to quality and value.
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you; this is truly the “hole in the wall” that stands as a testament to the saying that good things come in small packages. If you're searching for authentic New York-style pizza in Muskogee, look no further. For every slice you savor, you'll taste the dedication and love that go into each creation. So grab your friends, place your order, and get ready to experience the real deal at Lugos NY Pizza. You won’t regret it!
Pizza made from scratch in Muskogee! I had the sausage and the Margherita pizza. And the Buffalo wings! They are so delicious. I feel the freshness of the ingredients they use! I don’t normally eat pizza crust, but I finished the whole piece with this one.
It was super delicious! Crispy crust and fresh tasting ingredients. I got a 20in cheese and a 12in veggie. The veg was so delicious and the cheese was simply good! The staff was super cool. One was even dancing to AC/DC. Felt very welcoming
I had the absolute pleasure of visiting Lugos Pizza recently, and let me just say, this is hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m from Fort Smith, AR, and nothing around here even comes close to what Lugos is serving up in Muskogee, OK. What really made the experience special was getting to talk to the owners. They took the time to explain their journey, how they spent over 15 years learning the craft, attending the New York Pizza Convention, and dialing in every detail of their process. I was blown away to learn that they ferment real, active yeast for three days to make their dough. That kind of care and craftsmanship shows in every bite. Even more impressive, they told me how they spent time perfecting their recipe specifically for the Muskogee climate before opening. That level of thoughtfulness and commitment is rare and it paid off. Now I’ll be honest, from the outside, Lugos might look like a bit of a hole in the wall. But in my experience, those are always the hidden gems, and Lugos proves that 100 percent. When you walk in and see the owner working behind the counter, you just know it’s going to be good, and they didn’t disappoint for a second. Whether you're a pizza lover or just someone who appreciates real, quality food made by passionate people, you owe it to yourself to try Lugos. This place is the real deal. I’ll be making the drive from Fort Smith regularly. It’s that good.
Best product at the best price! If you want quality, quantity, and price.... this is your place. The Stromboli has provided 3 meals. The marinara is fresh and light. Don't order if you expect a greasy product. The ingredients are fresh and the crust is perfect.
Man I am absolutely HAPPY HAPPY with this HUGE 20” pizza! Crust, sauce, and fixings were all great quality. The Price is an excellent value. & THE TASTE 100% OH YEAH! Absolutely will be back! I had a 20” 1/2 All Meat 1/2 The Works
Their New York style pizza & calzone is the best pizza we have in our city hands down. The man running the store the night we came in was friendly & answered our questions. We ordered the 20 inch Veggie then chose mushrooms & bell pepper for our calzone. We walked in to order since it was our first time there. Our wait time was 20 minutes which was very reasonable for a Friday night plus you can't rush greatness. This is a pick up & go pizza shop since they don't have a dining area. We will definitely be back!
I have been going to Lugo's since the opened and all I can say is if you want Real NY style pizza they are the only place to go out side of NY city. These guys are not a chain they actually love pizza and know how to make NY style pizza like they do in the New York area. Having lived in may place all over the country I can say they make the only pizza I have ever had outside of NY that actually is true NY style . You can actually get a 20" pizza rather than the chain stores so called 16" large pizza.
You know that “hole in the wall” place that everyone talk about. The one that’s small, off the beaten path but always has the BEST food around? THIS IS THAT PLACE!!! There is no dine-in, no tables, and the decorum consists of two folding chairs and an old office chair, but that’s ok. They aren’t there to make you feel warm and cozy, they aren’t there too look at, they are there for one reason and that is to make great pizza, and they do that in spades. The two dudes working the evening on 6-7-25 were cool and friendly. Not overly talkative but helpful if you had questions or wanted suggestions. I ordered the basic pepperoni and cheese and it was perfection in a box. I don’t know how they do it but somehow the crust is thin and firm, it has a light crisp and yet it’s still soft. What kind of witchcraft is that??? All I can say is that this is my new go to for football season, birthdays, Valentine’s Day, Flag Day, NYE, basically all of the days.